You know the person I mean, don’t you.
The one who wears their “special face.” Whose mood sets the temperature for the whole staffroom. When they’re flat, everyone feels it within the hour.
One person’s low mood can spread faster than you’d like — and before you know it, it’s not just their problem. It’s the room’s.
The team absorb it. They tiptoe. They compensate. They do that person’s work, because it’s easier than the alternative.
Here’s the bit that can catch us out: we say “it’s just how they are, it’s their personality.”
I was a teacher, then a business leader, and a rule of thumb I always apply is this: would I say that about a child in my class?
I don’t think I would. I’d say it’s their behaviour, behaviour is a choice, and I’d want to help them see the impact of that choice. So why wouldn’t I do the same for a member of my team? And why would I let the rest of my team carry the cost of not doing it?
I don’t say this as a heartless robot. It’s something I’ve had to learn. Talking to an adult about their conduct is one of the harder conversations you’ll have. But it’s one of the most important — because your team, and your pupils, are absorbing it too. (Part Two of the Teachers’ Standards includes making “a positive contribution to the wider life and ethos of the school.” Conduct isn’t a side issue. It’s the job.)
So how do you tackle it, kindly and effectively?
In my book (Successful Difficult Conversations in School), I describe a head I worked with who had a member of staff who was excellent in almost every way — but whose behaviour was intimidating, and whose reaction to any challenge was extreme: shouting, storming out. It was scary.
What changed things was a simple technique: picture two futures. World one — nothing changes, the behaviour continues, and the cost keeps building, for the team and eventually for the person’s own career. World two — the issue is addressed, and the person becomes someone the team can rely on again.
Once the head could see both futures clearly, the conversation stopped feeling optional. It was hard. But she made the change, and it paid off for both of them.
You can run the same check on the person you’re picturing right now. If you want to see what avoiding it is costing your team, my cost of conflict calculator will do the maths for you.
A few things that help once you’ve decided to go ahead:
- Name the behaviour, not the person. “When you ***, it makes me feel ***”
- Separate impact from intent. They may have no idea their mood is landing on anyone else. Telling them, calmly, is a kindness — not an accusation.
- Give them something to do with it. A question like “what would help this week?” turns the conversation from what might feel like ‘a telling-off’ into a plan.
Most of the time, this conversation is shorter and easier than the one you’ve been rehearsing in your head. I’ve heard from plenty of leaders who’ve had it — and just as often, from the person on the receiving end, thanking them for it afterwards, usually a little after the event, once the dust has settled.
And if it doesn’t shift things? You’ve still done the right thing early — which makes whatever comes next far more straightforward than if you’d waited.
Here’s to catching it before it spreads, Sonia ❤️
P.S. Next week: a two-minute version of this conversation, for the small stuff — lateness, a slipping deadline — before it becomes a decade-long problem.
Don’t forget, if one person’s mood or behaviour is affecting your staffroom right now, don’t wait for it to spread further — just get in touch for a chat because we might be able to help. Simply reply to this email or go to Contact us – Heads Up.
(And it won’t be a sales call, unless you ask us to tell you about our services.)